avevo letto il libro tanti anni fa, mi
era piaciuto e mi aveva impressionato molto, ora ho visto il film, a tratti
insostenibile da quanto ti coinvolge.
Dalton Trumbo è uno che ha scritto molte sceneggiature,
"Spartacus" fra le altre (e mica Kubrick lavorava con incapaci) e
pare che Buñuel abbia collaborato a "E Johnny prese il
fucile"
Dalton Trumbo ha girato solo questo film ed è un film immenso, per i miei
gusti.
peggio per chi non lo guarda - Ismaele
…E Johnny prese il fucile, così anticinematografico nel suo modo
di raccontare la guerra, va ad essere, insieme a pellicole "una
tantum" come Freaks (1932),
uno di quegli esempi di cinema che si può fare una volta sola, che non può più
essere ripetuto, almeno così per com'è stato espresso la prima volta. Ne
consegue che, al di là dei meriti squisitamente tecnici, fra i pro e i contro,
questo primo e unico film di Trumbo, Gran Premio della Giuria a Cannes del
1971, è una pellicola unica nel suo genere, difficilmente paragonabile e
assolutamente imperdibile da tutti coloro che amano cimentarsi con i messaggi
artistici più complessi e destabilizzanti.
I became an instant pacifist when I saw this movie at the age of 16. Prior
to this, I had been a supporter of the war in Vietnam, and had fully intended
to enlist when I was old enough. My father, a veteran of WW2 and Korea, took me
to see this movie when it was first released, to help cure me of my delusion
about the glory of war. He was very successful in that undertaking. While I
haven't seen the movie in 34 years, I cannot deny it had a major influence on
my life. I'll never forget the horror I felt in seeing that poor soldier
trapped in his mind. I would strongly recommend telling anyone who is pro-war
to see this movie. You may help turn on others to the horrors of war.
One of cinema's greatest achievements. The film is an incredible
experience. The fact that you spend almost two hours watching the figure of
someone buried under sheets and that we are intrigued by every second of it,
testifies to the genius of the film. It's sad that most people remember this
movie as the one Metallica made a video for. No offense to the band, but this
JGHG is far more important than that. Dalton Trumbo's only directorial effort
and it is flawless. The majority of the film is told in a voiceover and like
"Twelve Angry Men" everything takes place in one room. Prepare to be
amazed.
I've never much liked anti-war films. They've never much stopped war, for
one thing. For another, they attract hushed and reverential praise which speaks
of their universality and the urgency of their messages. Most anti-war films
come so burdened with universality and urgency that the ads for them read like
calls to sunrise services.
Dalton Trumbo's "Johnny Got His
Gun" smelled like that kind of anti-war film. It came out of
the Cannes Film Festival with three awards and a slightly pious aroma, as if it
had been made for joyless Student Peace Union types of thirty-five years ago.
But it isn't like that at all. Trumbo has taken the most difficult sort of
material -- the story of a soldier who lost his arms, his legs, and most of his
face in a World War I shell burst -- and handled it, strange to say, in a way
that's not so much anti-war as pro-life. Perhaps that's why I admire it...
La structure narrative
de Johnny got his gun est audacieuse : les souvenirs et les
rêves sont en couleur et la dure réalité du présent est en noir et blanc, ce
qui amplifie la tristesse de l’état de Johnny. Il se souvient de sa
fiancée, de sa timidité dans la découverte d’un premier amour, de ses relations
avec son père (sublime séquence de la canne à pêche).Toutes ces scènes sont
poignantes car traitées avec beaucoup de tendresse et de pudeur.
L’identification du spectateur à Johnny devient bouleversante. Le contraste
saisissant avec l’horreur de sa situation actuelle ne cède jamais au chantage à
l’émotion. Mais les repères peuvent parfois se brouiller, ce qui donne lieu à
des scènes surréalistes. Dans une scène de cauchemar, Johnny imagine qu’un
rat est venu le dévorer et n’arrive plus à distinguer le rêve de la réalité. Il
s’imagine également en train de dialoguer avec un Christ totalement impuissant malgré
sa bonne volonté.
Dalton Trumbo ne
s’attaque pas seulement à la folie militaire et au cynisme de la science, mais
également à l’hypocrisie de la religion, ce qui le rapproche de son grand ami
Luis Bunuel dont on reconnaît d’ailleurs la griffe grâce à son sens de la
caricature féroce….
…Le
caractère universel et intemporel de l’œuvre conserve encore toute sa
force.L’absurdité de la guerre sera toujours à démontrer. La vision de Johnny
got his gun est une expérience douloureuse mais nécessaire, tout
comme Nuit et Brouillard d’Alain Resnais. Mais malgré sa
noirceur radicale, Johnny got his gun ne cherche pas pour
autant à donner une impression désespérée. Il est carrément impossible
d’oublier cette scène bouleversante où l’infirmière trouve enfin le moyen de
communiquer avec Johnny afin de pouvoir lui souhaiter un Joyeux Noël,
persogiàdisuo 21 ottobre 2012 12:51
RispondiEliminaNon mi risulta che Bunuel abbia collaborato a questa sceneggiatura, comunque il libro è notevole, il film non l'ho visto!
Ismaele 21 ottobre 2012 13:58
il film si trova in italiano:)
sul rapporto Buñuel-Trumbo (anch'io ero dubbioso) ho trovato questo:
…Trumbo wrote his first draft of the Johnny Got His Gun screenplay in 1964 after Spanish director Luis Bunuel, whom he had met in Mexico shortly before, expressed serious interest in it. Both he and Bunuel were pleased with the adaptation, but financing fell through…
(http://www.tcm.com/this-month/article/241079%7C0/Johnny-Got-His-Gun.html)
…"They wanted to know if I'd do a screenplay for Bunuel," Trumbo said. "Hell, I said I'd do a screenplay, and be his secretary, and carry his briefcase and do his laundry. I went down to
Mexico and spent some time with Bunuel, of which I best remember the four-hour lunches which averaged out to about a bottle of wine an hour. And then I came back to California and went to work, and by the time I had the screenplay completed, the producer was out of money and Bunuel was back in Spain, broke.
"I've always been interested in how Bunuel would have made it. I think he would have savagely attacked democracy. I imagine his approach would have been more shocking than my own. I've tended more to center on the young man, the soldier, and let you draw your own conclusions about the system that put him where he was…
(http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/19710905/PEOPLE/109050301)
…Non bastasse una produzione copiosa spalmata su quarantotto anni di carriera, la fervida mente dell'autore ha concepito una lunga serie di progetti mai portati a termine: un paio di film porno, un documentario su Goya a un altro sulla schizofrenia, una vita di Gesù, una serie di adattamenti di romanzi talvolta girati - in seguito - da altri: "E Johnny prese il fucile", di cui scrisse la sceneggiatura insieme a Dalton Trumbo, "Il monaco" da Lewis, "Là-bas/L'abisso" da Huysmans. Aggiungiamo che don Luis avrebbe dovuto comparire in "Io e Annie" al posto di McLuhan (ma rifiutò) e girare "I prigionieri dell'oceano", progetto poi affidato a Hitchcock. E che pare abbia effettivamente girato, negli anni trenta, quattro film "orrendi" che non ha firmato…
(http://www.ondacinema.it/monografie/scheda/luis_bunuel.html)
"Johnny Got His Gun" is a Bunuel? Did he direct a sequence?
Well, Dalton Trumbo met Luis Buñuel in Mexico (1964), and he expressed serious interest in his book "Johnny got his gun". Both he and Bunuel were pleased with the script adaptation, but financing fell through.
Buñuel helped and supported Trumbo, directing what it would have turned out to be his only movie. It was Buñuel's idea to cast Donald Sutherland (as Jesus, in scenes allegedly added by Bunuel)
(http://www.listal.com/list/favorite-luis-bunuel-movies)